A reflection on Richard Sutton's "Bitter Lesson," arguing that while his critique of LLMs' inefficiency and lack of continual learning is valid, imitation learning is a complementary and necessary precursor to true reinforcement learning, much like fossil fuels were to renewable energy.
Jeremy Berman, winner of the ARC-AGI v2 public leaderboard, discusses his novel evolutionary approach that refines natural language descriptions instead of code. He explores the idea of building AI that synthesizes new knowledge by constructing deductive "knowledge trees" rather than merely compressing data into "knowledge webs," touching on the fundamental challenges of reasoning, continual learning, and creativity in current models.
Richard Sutton, a foundational figure in reinforcement learning, argues that Large Language Models (LLMs) are a flawed paradigm for achieving true intelligence. He posits that LLMs are mimics of human-generated text, lacking genuine goals, world models, and the ability to learn continually from experience. Sutton advocates for a return to the principles of reinforcement learning, where an agent learns from the consequences of its actions in the real world, a method he believes is truly scalable and fundamental to all animal and human intelligence.